Rubber Tracks vs. Steel Tracks

On the introductory page of this blog I invite companies or individuals to submit articles that may be educational or interesting. This article was submitted by HXRT, an Australian manufacturer of rubber track. (www.hxrt.com.au) Though not strictly related to automation, this is the first contribution I have received so I am posting it. Though these tracks are used for tracked vehicles this can be loosely related to material handling applications. -Frank

The Difference between Rubber Tracks and Steel Tracks

Weighing track options for mini excavators or skid steer loaders can put you in quite a dilemma. It is really confusing to choose between rubber tracks and steel tracks for your machines. You need to choose the material of the tracks based on the costs, the terrain in which you plan to use them and the weather. These factors play a significant role in the durability of tracks.

HXRT Rubber Track

To begin with, let us first understand why one should use continuous tracks over rubber tyres. Continuous tracks offer a large surface area, which distributes the weight of heavy vehicles better than tyres would. Tracked vehicles have better mobility on rough terrains, and are tougher than regular tyres and hence offer more durability than the latter. They offer better results in pulling and pushing large and heavy loads, whereas one can expect wheeled vehicles to dig into the ground.

As you are now aware of why one should prefer continuous tracks, let us now understand the difference between rubber tracks and steel tracks and which one serves a better purpose. Steel tracks are known for their longer life. Many experts feel that steel tracks do not wear off like rubber tracks and have double the life. They are popular to deal with stress better. Yet, steel tracks are noisier than rubber tracks. However, this can be an advantage for the safety of other people. The noise will make them aware that you are coming, giving them ample time to move.

Rubber tracks are a good option for pavements as they move easily on concrete finishes. However, on muddy roads, bushes and rocks, steel tracks are a better option. Rubber tracks provide a much smoother and quieter ride than steel tracks. So, if your work stays away from rough terrains, rubber tracks are definitely for you.

Rubber tracks lack slack in the system, so, if any debris gets between the tyre and the track, it will add tension to the track, axle and eventually the chain. Thus, steel tracks with rubber pads effectively help deal with this problem as they have slack in the track.

Steel tracks damage hard terrain like asphalt pavement. They often cause damage to less firm terrains too due to their sharp edges. To avoid damage to different types of terrains, rubber tracks offer the ideal solution. So, if you want to finish your work smoothly, without damaging any pavement, you can opt for rubber tracks or steel tracks with rubber pads.

Share
Posted in Applications, Guest Posts, Vendors and Manufacturers Tagged with: ,
6 comments on “Rubber Tracks vs. Steel Tracks
  1. Hey we sell rubber tracks too! How cool is that!?

  2. Heavy material equipment is most crucial part to count overall productivity. your blog focused on good fact. Trident also manufacturer & supplier of wide range of tracks for different models of mini excavators, compact track loaders, skid loaders, HDD rigs, carrier vehicles, combine harvesters, tracked dumpers, crawler cranes. etc.

  3. narendra says:

    I would like to run crawler robot on steel pipe alingments which have some gap in between all lines. Pipe diameter is 38.1mm and gap between two pipes is 61.9mm so to run on a steel pipe surface which track will be good so that it will not stuck while running ?

    Thank you in advance

    • Frank says:

      You go girl! (A silly American saying meaning “go for it”).

      You know, years ago somebody wanted to write a guest blog for their company about these steel and rubber tracks. While I like heavy equipment, it doesn’t really relate to automation and industrial controls in any way that I can see. I put it on here, and on my Google Analytic’s page it shows that people actually do seem to read it. It’s even gotten a few comments on it, like yours.

      The thing is, I am a controls and machine building guy, and I don’t know any more about rubber or steel tracks than what I read here. There seem to be several links in the article and comments to people who do know that sort of thing, but at this point I just leave it on here because its kind of funny. People link to each others sites just to get more traffic, and I think that’s the case here.

      I hope you can also help out the guy who was trying to attach things to his wall with rubber tacks too. I wouldn’t choose rubber as my primary tack-making material, but there are a lot of things I am not so well versed on, so maybe someone can help. Good luck with your robot!

  4. Kylie Dotts says:

    It makes sense that an excavator’s tracks would allow it to evenly distribute its weight over an area. I would assume that this would help the vehicle travel over rougher kinds of terrain easier than a wheeled vehicle would. If you’re doing a construction project, this would be important because you never know what it’s going to be like until you get there.

1 Pings/Trackbacks for "Rubber Tracks vs. Steel Tracks"
  1. […] steel tracks tend to last longer than rubber ones. However, rubber tracks provide for a much smoother and quieter ride. Another good reason to use rubber tracking instead of steel is because it causes less damage to […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*